Forget the book description:
She thought she’d escaped her poisonous past…
Thirteen years ago, Maggie Ellis left her small town and vowed to never return. In her rearview mirror were two men she loved and an ominous secret that would forever haunt her.
Now, tragedy has brought her back, and she’s determined to forget that fateful night. But in a town like Myers, with familiar faces and chilling memories lurking around every corner, moving on is easier said than done.
Before the ink can dry on the closing documents for her new residence, Maggie begins to feel unsettled. In every room, there’s the unmistakable sensation she’s being watched. The strange sounds, odd smells, and bizarre occurrences only add to her paranoia.
There’s something sinister about her new home…
When she discovers the devastating truth about the house and its grim history, Maggie’s worst fears are realized. In order to survive, she must unearth the secrets she’d always planned to keep buried.
After all, they say that home is where the heart is, but as Maggie knows, home is also where the skeletons lie.
Seamlessly blurring the edges between psychological thriller and romantic suspense, million-copy bestselling author Kiersten Modglin brings us a dark and twisted romantic thriller, perfect for fans of Verity, Tell Me Lies, The Ghost Writer, and YOU.
Because it is misleading. If your impression was ‘haunted house suspense story,’ well know that’s only a small aspect of the book. I went into this thinking it was a mystery/suspense so I went in blind, and if you like to go into stories that way, skip my review. But if content and genre matters, keep reading.
What this book serves up is romantic suspense with just a side helping of mystery. Calling it a psychological thriller is a huge stretch. And before romance readers get too excited about it, it’s best to also know this is first and foremost, a love triangle drama. Given all the men in the protagonist’s orbit and the angst surrounding them, that should be disclosed in the blurb. It’s such a huge foundation of the story.
On the plus side, because it’s more romance than mystery, it’s
more character driven than many mysteries that are solely plot driven. On the
downside, the characters are…well best to break them down.
Upon her mother’s passing, Maggie returns to her hometown
and uses her inheritance money to buy the house she always adored. Once she
gets there, she finds that it needs more work than she remembered and that the
two men she left behind aren’t so far away. Told via Maggie’s first person POV,
the chapters alternate between the past (13 years prior) and the present, where
really not a lot has changed.
Thirteen years ago, back in college, Maggie is going to
confess her feeling to her childhood best friend, Clayton. But his big break
into showbiz comes a calling before she gets the chance. When he returns to
town a few months down the road with a fiancé, Maggie is hurt and takes the local
bartender, Tucker, up on his offer to make Clayton jealous.
For a romance, Maggie and Tucker’s ‘fake’ dating is cute and
they have a good rapport with each other. I definitely felt the romantic vibes
and relationship building with them. Tucker
is a sweetheart! I was rooting for him
from very early on…until I wasn’t sure he didn’t deserve better than Maggie,
who was just too far up Clayton’s butt.
Holy wishy-washy Maggie. I went from liking her, to wanting
to shake some sense into her, to wanting to slap her silly. While I could give her some leeway with not
seeing things when she was younger, by the “present,” she was old enough and
lived enough that she should have clued in. It’s not like Tucker wasn’t
spelling it out for her. And if Maggie could have read people better, she wouldn't have even been in a love triangle in the first place. She also could have saved herself a lot of heartache by simply communicating effectively with these men. The 13-year gap in the timelines just makes the whole thing pathetic and problematic.
Clayton was both a tool and a doofus. And the more the story progressed, the more I couldn’t stand him and by extension was getting beyond annoyed with Maggie for indulging him. And then throw in appearances from Maggie’s ex-boyfriend, Nick, who she broke up with before coming home, and there's more relationship drama and distractions from the house mystery.
The majority of the novel is just that—love triangle drama. That’s not to say the story doesn’t deliver some twists, because it does. But as far as a thriller goes, it’s really not one. Her creepy house is not just a slow burn mystery, but basically on the back burner for more than half of the book. There are some eerie vibes regarding the house and the backstory was unsettling, though ultimately not explored enough especially after its connection is revealed. There's also some missed opportunity to develop the mystery/suspense, and I don’t mean the supernatural kind because I was more than fine without it. Ultimately, the ending felt abrupt and rushed, and there really wasn’t enough comeuppance.
Anyone reading for the “romance,” here's the safety details:*Title borrowed from the library’s e-loan app. All
reviews written by Book-Bosomed Book Blog are honest opinions.
















